W. Stephen Tait, Ph.D. Chief Science Officer & Principal Consultant, Pair O Docs Professionals, LLC Corrosion Corner Commercial life vs. Service life Hello, everyone. Last month, I discussed several corrosion and statistical technical terms that are relevant to spray package corrosion. This month, I’ll expand that discussion by focusing on the relationship between commercial life and service life. These two lives can be used to determine if corrosion is too severe to market a formula-package system or slow enough that failures will not be observed by consumers before the product is exhausted from the package and it is recycled. My original intention for this article was to discuss the relationship between commercial life and service life. While writing, I realized I also need to provide a more detailed discussion about what factors affect the magnitude of both commercial and service lives. Consequently, the discussion this month will cover the relationship between the two lives and the next one or two issues will provide more detailed discussions on the factors that determine them. Let’s review the definitions of each. Service life Service life is the time when the package performs as specified. In other words, the package sprays and does not leak. Service life is determined by the type of package materials, package metal surface treatment (e.g., coated or uncoated), the physical form of your formula (e.g., emulsion or single phase) and the chemical composition of your formula. Service life is estimated from corrosion data from either a long-term storage test or electrochemical corrosion testing. Commercial life Commercial life is the time after filling that it takes for consumers to completely use the product and recycle the package. Commercial life is a function of the economy. Figure 1 graphically illustrates a generic commercial life profile for containers filled during a given manufacturing batch (lot). Figure 1 has two curves because an actual commercial profile is affected by the economy. A growing economy normally decreases commercial life (short filling-to-recycle times) and a stagnant or declining economy normally increases commercial life (long filling-to-recycle times). The Y-axis is the fraction of the containers from the batch that are empty (completely consumed) and recycled after a given time. The X-axis is the time after batch filling is completed. The time axis would be in days and is left blank to keep the curves generic. The two vertical dashed lines in Figure 1 illustrate that the filling-to-recycle time ranges between 26 Spray February 2015 approximately 2.5 and 3.25 time-units; one for a hypothetical growing economy and the other for a hypothetical stagnant or declining economy, respectively. Figure 1 also illustrates that commercial life could be defined in several ways. For example, commercial life could be defined as the time when 90% or 95% of the filled containers are exhausted and recycled instead of 100%. It has been our experience that each type of formula-package system has a different commercial life range. Figure 2 illustrates a situation where the estimated service life is greater than the commercial life. The second commercial curve is omitted for simplicity.
Spray Feb 2015
To see the actual publication please follow the link above